PUBLISHED: 10:20 EST, 5 April 2012 | UPDATED: 10:35 EST, 5 April 2012
Half a decade into the deepest U.S. housing crisis since the 1930s, many Americans are hoping the crisis is finally nearing its end.
House sales are picking up across most of the country, the plunge in prices is slowing and attempts by lenders to claim back properties from struggling borrowers dropped by more than a third in 2011, hitting a four-year low.
But a painful part two of the slump looks set to unfold: Many more U.S. homeowners face the prospect of losing their homes this year as banks pick up the pace of foreclosures.
Seesawing: House sales have picked up, plunging prices have slowed and attempts by lenders to claim back properties from borrowers dropped by more than a third in 2011 but a painful part two of the slump looks set to unfold
‘We are right back where we were two years ago. I would put money on 2012 being a bigger year for foreclosures than 2010,’ said Mark Seifert, executive director of Empowering & Strengthening Ohio’s People (ESOP), a counseling group with 10 offices in Ohio.
‘Last year was an anomaly, and not in a good way,’ he said.
In 2011, the ‘robo-signing’ scandal, in which foreclosure documents were signed without properly reviewing individual cases, prompted banks to hold back on new foreclosures pending a settlement.
Five major banks eventually struck that settlement with 49 U.S. states in February. Signs are growing the pace of foreclosures is picking up again, something housing experts predict will again weigh on home prices before any sustained recovery can occur.
Foreclosure jump: Mortgage servicing provider Lender Processing Services reported that U.S. foreclosure starts jumped 28 percent in January with more expected to follow
Mortgage servicing provider Lender Processing Services reported in early March that U.S. foreclosure starts jumped 28 percent in January.
More conclusive national data is not yet available. But watchdog group, 4closurefraud.org which helped uncover the ‘robo-signing’ scandal, says it has turned up evidence of a large rise in new foreclosures between March 1 and 24 by three big banks in Palm Beach County in Florida, one of the states hit hardest by the housing crash
U.S. foreclosure starts jumped 28 percent in January
- Deutsche Bank foreclosures were up 47 percent from 2011
- Wells Fargo foreclosures rose 68 percent
- Bank of America foreclosures jumped nearly seven-fold — 251 starts versus 37 in the same period in 2011
More than one in four American homeowners owed more than their home’s worth in the fourth quarter of 2011
Some 9.5 million homes are still at risk of default
Although foreclosure starts were 50 percent or more lower than for the same period in 2010, those begun by Deutsche Bank were up 47 percent from 2011.
Those of Wells Fargo’s rose 68 percent and Bank of America’s, including BAC Home Loans Servicing, jumped nearly seven-fold — 251 starts versus 37 in the same period in 2011.
Bank of America said it does not comment on data provided by other sources. Wells Fargo and Deutsche Bank did not comment.
Housing experts say localized warning signs of a new wave of foreclosure are likely to be replicated across much of the United States.
Online foreclosure marketplace RealtyTrac estimated that while foreclosures dropped slightly nationwide in February from January and from February 2011, they rose in 21 states and jumped sharply in cities like Tampa (64 percent), Chicago (43 percent) and Miami (53 percent).
RealtyTrac CEO Brandon Moore said the ‘numbers point to a gradually rising foreclosure tide as some of the barriers that have been holding back foreclosures are removed.’
One big difference to the early years of the housing crisis, which was dominated by Americans saddled with the most toxic subprime products — with high interest rates where banks asked for no money down or no proof of income — is that today it’s mostly Americans with ordinary mortgages whose ability to meet payment have been hit by the hard economic times.
Banks’ stats: Foreclosures by Wells Fargo rose 68 percent in comparison to 2011 while Deutsche Bank’s rose by 47 percent and Bank of America jumped nearly seven-fold
‘The subprime stuff is long gone,’ said Michael Redman, founder of 4closurefraud.org. ‘Now the folks being affected are hardworking, everyday Americans struggling because of the economy.’
Until December 2010, Daniel Burns, 52, had spent his working life in the trucking industry as a long-haul driver and manager. When daily loads at the small family business where he worked tailed off, he lost his job.
Unable to cover his mortgage, Burns received a grant from a government fund using money repaid from the 2008 bank bailout. That grant is due to expire in early 2013 and Burns is holding out on hopeful comments from his former employer that he might get his job back if the economy recovers.
‘If things don’t pick up, I will be out on the street,’ he said, staring from his living room window at two abandoned houses over the road in the middle-class Cleveland suburb of Garfield Heights, the noise of traffic from a nearby Interstate highway filling the street.
Resumed: Housing experts predict the rise in foreclosures as some of the barriers that have been holding back foreclosures are removed
Underscoring the uncertainty of his situation, Burns’ cell phone rings and a pre-recorded message announces that his unemployment benefits are due to be cut off in April.
A bit further up the shore of Lake Erie, Cristal Fell, who works night shifts entering data for a trucking company in Toledo, has fallen behind on her mortgage a second time because her ex-husband lost his job and her overtime was cut.
‘The hangover from this crisis will far outlast the party of the boom years’
– Zillow chief economist Stan Humphries
‘Once you get behind it’s so hard to catch up,’ she said.
Fell, a mother of four, hopes the economy will gather enough speed to help her avoid any risk of losing her home. Her ex-husband has found a new job and she is getting more overtime, so she hopes she can catch up on her mortgage by the fall.
Burns and Fell are the new face of the U.S. housing crisis: Middle class, suburban or rural with a conventional 30-year fixed mortgage at a reasonable interest rate, but unemployed or underemployed.
Victims: In today’s mortgage crisis it’s mostly now Americans with ordinary mortgages whose ability to meet payment have been hit simply by the hard economic times
Although the national unemployment rate has fallen to 8.3 percent from its peak of 10 percent in October 2009, nearly 13 million Americans remain jobless, meaning many are struggling to keep up with their mortgage payments.
Real estate company Zillow Inc says more than one in four American homeowners were ‘under water’ or owed more than their homes were worth in the fourth quarter of 2011. The crisis has wiped out some $7 trillion in U.S. household wealth.
‘We’re seeing more people coming through who have good loans with reasonable interest rates,’ said Ed Jacob, executive director of non-profit lender Neighborhood Housing Services of Chicago Inc, which provides foreclosure counseling. ‘But in many households only one person works now instead of two, or they had their hours cut.’
Prediction: Mark Seifert of the non-profit group East Side Organizing Project (ESOP) believes the housing economy is right back where it was two years ago, betting 2012 to be a bigger year for foreclosures than 2010
‘The answer to the housing crisis now is job creation.’
Zillow expects the resurgence in foreclosures this year, combined with excess inventory of unsold, bank-owned homes will contribute to a 3.7 percent national decline in prices before the market hits bottom in 2013 and stays there until 2016.
‘The hangover from this crisis will far outlast the party of the boom years,’ said Zillow chief economist Stan Humphries.
Getting through the remaining foreclosures and dealing with the resulting flood of homes on the market in the wake of the bank settlement is a necessary part of the healing process for the U.S. housing market, he added.
Demonstrations: A member of the Occupy Wall St movement points to a foreclosure notice posted on a Wells Fargo branch during a National Day of Action demonstration in New York in February
According to leading broker dealer Amherst Securities, some 9.5 million homes are still at risk of default and in February it said it expected to see the uptick in foreclosures start to hit in March and April.
There is other evidence that many of the foreclosures that did not happen in 2011 will happen this year.
A January report by the Neighborhood Economic Development Advocacy Project in New York found that in the first half of 2011 the number of 90-day pre-foreclosure notices in New York City outnumbered court foreclosure actions by a ratio of 14 to one, indicating that while proceedings were initiated against many homeowners, they were left incomplete.
‘Now the banks have a settlement, foreclosure numbers for 2012 are going to be high,’ said NEDAP co-director Josh Zinner.
Reduced: One real estate company says more than one in four American homeowners owed more than their homes were worth in the fourth quarter of 2011
A recent survey by the California Reinvestment Coalition, an umbrella group of nearly 300 non-profit groups in the state, of member agencies found 75 percent of respondents expected increased demand for their foreclosure prevention services in 2012 but more than a third had to scale back services because of funding cuts.
‘Funding is a major concern given what our members expect for this year,’ said associate director Kevin Stein.
All this has non-profits intensifying calls for the Federal Housing Finance Agency to drop its opposition to allowing the government-backed mortgage giants Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac it regulates to reduce principal for underwater homeowners.
Principal reduction involves reducing the amount borrowers owe in order to make a loan modification affordable for struggling homeowners. Republicans and the FHFA oppose principal reduction because of the risk of ‘moral hazard’- that homeowners who do not need help will seek to abuse largesse and have their mortgages reduced too.
Efforts: The housing crisis alone wiped out some $7 trillion in U.S. household wealth while a Chase spokeswoman said their bank has helped 775,000 borrowers stay in their homes since early 2009, avoiding foreclosure more often than have foreclosed
ESOP in Ohio engages in ‘hits’ on Chase branches — they say Chase is the least accommodating major bank when it comes to working with struggling homeowners — where they try to hand letters to bank mangers calling on chief executive Jamie Dimon to lobby FHFA head Edward DeMarco for principal reductions.
A Chase spokeswoman said the bank has made ‘extensive efforts’ to work with homeowners, helping 775,000 borrowers stay in their homes since early 2009, avoiding foreclosure ‘more than twice as often as we have had to foreclose.’
Housing groups like ESOP maintain, as they have throughout the housing crisis, that unless the FHFA embraces widespread principal reduction, many more under water borrowers face losing their homes.
‘Until banks engage in meaningful principal reduction as a matter of course,’ ESOP’s Seifert said after a recent protest at a Chase branch in Cleveland, ‘this crisis will not end.’